War of the Worlds Invasion logo

H.G. Wells' War of the Worlds (AKA Invasion, 2005)

H.G Wells War of the Worlds, AKA Invasion.

This is certainly the 2nd best War of the Worlds movie of 2005, but that may be damning it with very faint praise. The Pendragon version was a huge disappointment, while the Steven Spielberg film is simply one of the best (if not the best) alien invasion films ever made. So this War of the Worlds film (it was called Invasion in the UK due to copyright reasons) is pretty much stuck uncomfortably between a rock and a hard place.

At first glance, it looks like this straight to video production has all the hallmarks of a blatant rip off. But is this really just a hurried and cynical film made to ride on the coat tails of other peoples marketing budgets? The answer is a guarded no. It's hard to deny the serendipity of the release (to coincide with the Spielberg film), and the production company behind this movie (called the The Asylum) definitely fit the bill of a B-movie outfit with a pile em high, shoot em cheap philosophy. As exhibit A, they have made some gloriously titled productions. How about "Jolly Roger: Massacre at Cutter's Cove", or "Death Valley: The Revenge of Bloody Bill" and my personal favourite, Max Knight: Ultra Spy. (What does it mean when a movie company uses the colon sign in so many of their movie titles?) None of these movies are exactly renowned as cinematic masterpieces as a check of the reviews on the Internet Movie Database will quickly reveal, but since I've not seen any of them, I'm not about to cast stones.

So does their War of the Worlds fit their supposed modus operandi? Well, not quite, first and foremost because all the essential elements of The War of the Worlds are present and correct. Giant striding war machines? Check (though with 6 instead of 3 legs), Aliens coming to earth in Cylinders? Check. Key characters buried beneath a collapsed house? Check. The list goes on. Not bad given that this movie has come from nowhere and reportedly had a miniscule 1 million dollar budget. An equally positive clue that the moviemakers are serious (at least about the source material) is their choice of name for the lead character, George Herbert. What a nice idea. On the negative side, the publicity poster bears some striking similarities to Independence Day (which let's be honest, was an unofficial rip off of War of the Worlds anyway) and that implies that the makers are hardly shy of some liberal "borrowing" when it suits them.

c thomas howell. The cast is led by C Thomas Howell, whose credits are long and varied. He had an early role in ET the Extraterrestrial, and has recently shot a movie with Dennis Hopper. He plays the aforementioned George Herbert, and as we meet him it's the eve of his 10th wedding anniversary. George is an Astronomer, has a young (and when we first meet her, very naked) wife, and a pre-teen son. After a bit of laboured dialogue about his kid's cold (perhaps just to make a connection with the novel), we are treated to some scientifically ludicrous material about George and his kid using a telescope out in the back yard. First George tells his wife not to worry that it is broad daylight because they are going to look at a really bright star, then George tells his kid that he can't find what they are looking for because it's thousands of light years away, but then when his kid does spot something that "looks like a comet", George looks perplexed and says that "Mars" shouldn't look like a comet. Earth to George, assuming it was Mars he was looking for in the first place, it is not thousands of light years away and neither is it a "star." The object is of course a Martian Cylinder.

The sighting of the Cylinder is the cue for a bit of marital stress since George was meant to be going on an anniversary trip to Washington, but a call from "work" puts a stop to that. His wife and child set off on their own, and George goes looking for the "comet". As he drives through the night his car comes to a stop (along with radio and mobile phones), as a second object crashes to Earth. George is quickly on the scene, as rather improbably are a large crowd of onlookers. Crowd of onlookers next to pit. Where they came from in the middle of nowhere is a bit of a mystery. The scene plays out a little like the novel, with one of the onlookers trapped in the pit made by the impact. It does run a lot faster though, since within minutes a giant crab like machine has emerged and begins zapping the crowd. George flees, manages to make brief contact with his wife and promises to meet her in Washington. The dialogue continues to grate, as does the script. After packing up a few possessions, George bumps into a neighbour loading up his car. Hi says George, "does your car still work?" "I hope so says the neighbour." Hmm, I think you might want to have checked that before going to the bother of loading the car. It's a really strange stilted little conversation, with all the urgency of two guys shooting the breeze about the state of the local football team, yet a few minutes later, George has climbed a nearby hill and is looking down on his town getting a good zapping by the Martians.

This really characterises the whole film. It's just a curiously aimless and lifeless experience. George spends an inordinate amount of time running back and forth, bumping into some characters and situations from the book, such as the lost soldier and the priest (with whom he becomes trapped), and one created specifically for the movie. This is a scenery chewing turn by Jake Busey (credited as William Busey) as Lt. Samuelson, an opportunist soldier keen on making the most of the invasion. Samuelson was either crazy before the invasion, or has been tipped over the edge in its aftermath; it's not clear which.

Martian war machine.So George runs and the alien war machines trap around randomly blasting people. There are few poorly staged scenes of death and destruction that look like someone took a muddy field and dropped a few old cars into it, and some occasional work for the makeup department as various disfigured and shell-shocked soldiers stumble past our hero. The special effects are unfortunately not that special, especially the CGI scenes of the Martian war machines grabbing people in their mechanical tentacles, but the War Machines themselves have moments when they look quite sinister, and certainly the designs (whilst far from the Tripods envisaged by Wells) are interesting.

So returning to my original comments, this is still the second best War of the Worlds movie of 2005, though by now, you will have probably reached the conclusion that this is not saying a lot. Without doubt it scores over the Pendragon movie in just about every conceivable way. The acting is much better, though hampered by a script that tries to be sophisticated, but simply flounders under the weight of it's own pretensions, and the effects (while poor) are a thousand times better. I also have to give credit to director (and writer) David Michael Latt who has come over in interviews as someone genuinely interested in making a good H.G. Wells movie. Alas, he hasn't actually achieved it, but then with such a low budget and the need to doubtless conform to certain B movie conventions (such as the gratuitous nudity) probably hampered his noble ambitions; though anyone hoping for more naked flesh after the opening scene will be sorely disappointed. Not then a very good adaptation of the novel, nor that good an alien invasion movie, but you could do a lot worse.


See also in:

Film & TV

The War of the Worlds by George Pal

The War of the Worlds by George Pal. The action relocates to cold war America, with the Martian war machines re-invented as sinister flying machines.

War of the Worlds, Hines.

The War of the Worlds. A creditable desire to make a movie set in the original Victorian era can't help this terrible production.

The War of the Worlds, Spielberg.

The War of the Worlds Steven Spielberg and Tom Cruise get a huge bang for their bucks in this massive re-imagining of the story.

home - books - comics - film - gallery - links - mars - music - news - radio - shop - timeline
about - advertise - contact - privacy